Observation Rubric: Domain 3

Complex Ideas Using Everyday Language

Conversations between the teacher and a small group of students engenders student expression of complex ideas using students’ everyday language resources (e.g., dialects, vernaculars, creoles, homelanguages) through modeling, elicitation, and affirmation.


 

Classroom Examples


 

Note: Scores not included

3a: Teacher Models Expression

  • Teacher uses lots of questioning, extending, and clarifying

  • Teacher uses terms such as “main idea”

  • Teacher consistently restates what students say and elaborates on their expression

  • Teacher uses rephrasing after students share in order to model her own thinking to help students with their idea expression

  • Teacher incorporates students’ everyday language into conversation and encourages use of students’ language of choice

3b: Teacher Elicits Complex Expression

  • Teacher positions self as learner and aims to expand on students’ thinking and expression by speaking as if she does not understand how to make the sandwich

  • Teacher prompts students to explain their steps in more detailed, specific ways and to provide clearer instructions for making a peanut butter and jelly sandwich

3c: Teacher Affirms and Extends Verbal and Nonverbal Expression

  • Teacher rephases for clarification and to extend students’ contributions with additional detail

  • Teacher acknowledges students’ language of choice and applies the way they speak to the activity

    • Students are allowed to use Pidgin (Hawaiʻi-creole English) when creating their own sentence about making a peanut butter and jelly sandwich

    • Teacher transcribes students’ sentences which use their everyday language

      • Example: “I like to put jelly, guava kine.” 

3d: Students Author Ideas with Everyday Language

  • All students use their own everyday language when expressing ideas, in this case Pidgin 

  • Students respond to teacher questioning using everyday language

  • Students participate in creating sentences for their collaborative story using their everyday language

  • Students operate as “knowers” and teach the teacher how to make a peanut butter and jelly sandwich by describing the sequencing steps

  • Topic of making sandwiches is familiar to students and encourages student expression and participation

  • Overlapping speech is a natural speech pattern for Hawaiʻi students. It is viewed as a positive and valuable aspect of this conversation raising the engagement of students and indicating that students are comfortable with the topic and learning environment